Stylefan, Etsy is a great idea! I also have a lovely seamstress who tailors my clothes perfectly where I live, though I imagine based on the prices she charges that it would be expensive to have something made from scratch. I guess it wouldn't hurt to ask her! More and more I love pants #1 and I haven't seen anything quite like it. They also don't look supercomplicated, though I don't sew, so what do I know...
binkle, yes, it's the third parties on Amazon that complicate things. I never had a terrible experience but I can see from reviews that it could happen. I checked reviews for the same seller (other items) and many reviewers complain of the quality or of having been sent the wrong item. I'll check out the new pants at Uniqlo! They had a cool high-waisted pair of wool pants that sat in my shopping cart but it sold out before I made my mind up. Serves me right... I wanted a wintry fabric!
Lynn--yes, the article posted by kkards definitely gave me pause. And now I can't bring myself to order those pants from Amazon! I do love the silhouette of widelegs; the ones you linked from JCP are right up my alley. I already have three pairs in a similar fabric (thinner, slinkier) and I live in them in the summer. But I wanted warmer options for winter... I might still keep the ones you suggested in mind since I love them so much for hotter weather.
Thanks everyone for your input--super helpful as always!