Hi all,

Well, you have seen all my Winners posts lately and been so helpful! I decided to return most of the toppers due to fit/versatility issues, so I have been looking for a longer, light, cozy topper that has an architectural drape, looks luxe and pulled together.

I've found these two at Winners and love them both for their versatility. What do you think? Should I keep one? None? Both?

#1: Vince reversible cardigan. I love the architectural shape of this cardigan and both colors. It is well made and light and I would wear both sides a ton, both with more professional and casual looks. It was quite expressive even at Winners prices ($350 down from $795) but I am inclined to keep due to versatility. What do you think? Does the color work for me?

#2: Rag and Bone convertible vest & topcoat
This is a topcoat with two pieces that can be buttoned together to wear as one piece, or wear each piece separately. Together it is a topcoat; alone each piece is a vest or a lighter cardigan. It is well thought out and well made.

I like this one too because I can wear it together for warmth to the office, and then wear one piece or another as a light layer indoors. The color works with my color scheme and the clean cut would work with many outfits.

My worry is these two are too similar, but the way the pieces come apart,I could actually wear both many different ways and they may complement each other.

What do you think? Keep one? Both? Return both?

This post has 9 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.