I have three pairs of brown heels. I haven’t worn any of them this year. I think I should only keep one pair - but which?

I wear heels 2-8 times a year I guess - and only for rare work meetings or socialising.

My dressier shoes are in the finds- if I was going to a party or function I would likely choose one of these.

I. Thrifted Italian heels - I forgot I found them pre pandemic - never worn. Pros - good quality and versatile for the whole year. Cons - do they skew retro?
2. Consignment cognac pumps- I have worn these about 6-8 times over two years - but not at all this year. Pros - lowest heel and high quality. Cons - I only like them with pants - with a skirt they skew dowdy.
3. Pewter sandals. Purchased 2008 when I was a bridesmaid and worn a lot from 2008-2014 ish - and not at all since 2018. Pros - classic style that doesn’t date. Cons - not as good quality as the others.

I think it’s worth keeping one pair as the colour is versatile. If you think 2 or 3 or none that’s also fine. After trying them on I have a preference but I could be persuaded.

Which is your pick?