I am totally the odd woman out on this subject. I bought a pair of gray suede Stuart Weitzman peep toe pumps that have a suede rose-ette detail on the vamp at the NAS last year. They are beauuuuutiful! As far as I can remember, I've only worn them with outfits with gray. And I've mostly only worn them in the spring and fall, because they look gorgeous with my hot pink toes sticking out. I live in CO, so bare legs aren't an option in the winter, plus they feel kind of matronly worn with tights.
Another reason I don't wear them a lot is that they're suede, and I'm kind of hard on suede. The shoes are so gorgeous (and comfortable) that I want to wear them for years. All of that said, I may decide to wear them a bit more with other colors this year. You all have inspired me!