Revisiting this once again...
The oval frames:
They do outline the shape of your beautiful eyes very nicely. However, I don't like how they are sitting on the top of your cheek. They look too small, thus making your face look chubby and overly round and too ... cheeky (but not in a good way). This is my issue too; I have a cherubic face and cheeks, which is why I gravitate towards rectangular frames. Now, this may be fixable if you got wider ovals, though maybe not, because you see how the frames are sitting on top of your cheek bone? These just seem to add pounds to your face, I'm afraid! (And will probably annoy you to no end).
Whereas the rectangular frames go straight across your cheeks, therefore minimizing them a tad. Plus most of the rectangular frames you've chosen are wider across, so your face to me looks thinner. Also they just look funkier and trendier.
#9 ... I think these are too small for your face.
#8... I like these.
I do like the color of #6 very much, and think it would work with most of your wardrobe.
#5... these seem more "safe" than the rest - it's the color. I think you want something bolder?
#3 ... color is too dark and not as flattering.
#1... these are cute! Yes, lopsided though. I have that issue too, and I'm sure it's my ears. But it does seem that you may be able to get these adjusted. I would explore that.
So for me it's #8, #6, or #1. Not in any particular order.
I don't know if this is true (Dani can you ask your DH?) but my optometrist always says that your eyebrows should show and not be covered up by the frame. So the frame either needs to hit below your eyebrow, or above it. All three of these seem to fit the bill.
Width is something else to watch out for - you don't want them narrower than your face but neither do you want them too wide. This is always the hardest part for me; I usually have to be relegated to children's frames to get the right fit. It's hard for me to tell if #1 is the right width, because of the angle of the photo.
I would go back one more time, and try 1, 6, 8 again. Take more photos including side views. And wear something pink, if you want to be able to wear these glasses with pink! I think you're very close to selecting. How exciting!!
I really want new frames too - even though I rarely wear my glasses out of the house - but unfortunately my doctor said I don't need to change my prescription, and my frugality won out (for a change, LOL). The glasses I have are rectangular though... and similar in color to some of these (a red, but a darker/browner red) .... but the frame is not quite as chunky as the ones you picked, therefore not as trendy.