At first, I read the subject line as, "Give the Gift of THE Crocs." I couldn't figure out what on earth that would be.
I wouldn't even take Crocs to a white elephant party, let alone give them to someone I expected to speak to me the next day. "Wow, you care about me so much you got me foam shoes......gee.....thanks." I know, I know--it's the thought that counts.
EDIT: Maya, actually--those are pretty cute. I'd wear them. I was thinking of those neon rubber things I see all over campus. Actually, we have personalized burnt orange Crocs with a white Longhorn logo on it, especially for UT. Those are the ones I see most often.