For the record, I am regular height - 5ft 6 - so not petite. I usually wear jeans in a size 25 or 26 at a regular length. I bought the Gap Girlfriends in a 24 Petite (so that they would be snug, cropped and lower in the rise). They do run TTS if you want the fit like the model. I merely didn't want them to fit that way - the point of this post!
Hah! HIGH FIVE, Lisa. That's amazing. I love these jeans. Waving at my jeans twin.
Suz, I didn't like the way the jeans fit in my regular size and length either. To Gryffin's point. Sometimes size manipulation is the solution to great fit. Perhaps give it another go.
Karie and Bonnie, SIZE DOWN.