I don't think the shoulders need to be taken in!

Agree. I am voting tall, as is. The shoulders don't seem sloppy to me. Moreover, taking it in would also change things in the bust area I suspect... which might not be the best bet. The regular fit just looks off in multiple areas.

Another vote for tall. And I was one of the ones who said to try the regular

Tall, and I wouldn't do anything to the shoulders.

Thank you all for helping me out.
Regular is packed and ready to go. I am glad I have ordered it though, otherwise I would fret that maybe it was a better fit...now I know!
I have an urge to get tags off the Tall size and wear it tomorrow as is. If the extra width of the shoulders and extra sleeve length bothers me I will consult my wonder mom about the alterations.
Thanks again!

I think I'm too late, but I also like the fit of the tall, it looks less boxy. I'm looking forward to how you mix up this jacket. It's a great color.So now are you donating a jacket from your wardrobe to make room for this one?

I think my eye is not as practiced as some of the other ladies, but to my eye, they both look quite nice on you - but I like the tall better, because of where it hits at the waist. The regular is a little too cropped, IMO

I don't think the tall needs to be altered, either

Tags were off the Tall size and I wore it today!
Lisa, as for "1 in - 1 out": I have already gave my Hinge cropped blazer to my niece when she was visiting last summer and this much better fitting jacket took its place You see, I was very patient with the replacement....