I like that turtleneck! I'll be waiting to hear reviews because DH would love me to get a chunky turtleneck this year (I wore a grey one on our first date and so he has a special fondness for the look).

I thought it was working for you because you have great legs, the jeans look great so you didn't need the waist definition.
So back in the day, my girlfriends and I used to wear bulky sweaters like this *as* outerwear. But we were not fab, lol. But maybe a collared shirt would look cute under this? Just speculating... I know you decided to return

Oh, thanks Jules. I think I could make it work with some effort but I am more into effortless these days Ariadne, how sweet of your husband - that JCrew turtleneck might be the sweater for you!

Ooo, I do like the look of the JCrew one. Hope it works out for someone here!