Update: My Madewell shirtdress and cardi arrived today! Both seem to be of excellent quality. Great fit, both true-to-size. Love the little puff-shoulders on the dress; I was skeptical but they give just the right bit of structure and are very subtle. The cardi is a departure for me, but the length and volume are spot-on for this style and the wool is soft! They look great together, and I like that I'll be able to get extra mileage out of the dress as tunic and topper. I will post pics later this week.