A little update. I finally got a chance to steam out both skirts and try them on at home with various tops, jackets, and footwear.
The AllSaints is a keeper. I love the luxe fabric, the print is lovely, and the asymmetric hem right up my alley. It looks good with every pair of boots I tried. It also goes with a lot of my tops and jackets, thanks to the print that incorporates green, teal, and blue.
The Tahari is less of a winner. The fabric is not so luxe. It looks good with certain black boots and that’s about it. Tops are limited too — mostly just black. The blue in that skirt is a bit hard to match, and most of my blue items clashed with it a bit. But it does look good with denim jackets and those two pairs of black boots, black sandals as well. The other ding against it is the fit. It fits well across the hip but has quite a bit of extra fabric in the gathered waist (at the back) and the high hip. I could get it taken in, but is it really worth it?? So I have it set aside to return.