Thanks to all for responding. I will definitely report on the shoes when they arrive. Jenn, do you mean by “what happened to the black dresses”: how did I come to own all those black dresses that were never worn? Well, it’s probably like the crisp white blouse concept. “Everyone” needs one. I fell for that, I guess. The dresses fit me, and looked good on me to a certain extent, and I had places to wear them (3 were suitable for work), but they weren’t ME. I didn’t spend much on any of them, so I am just glad of that.
That is why I’m trying the black penny loafer concept with less expensive options. If I wear them often, and they feel like ME, I’m very likely to upgrade later. I did that with black oxfords - I wore out a pair of Born (reasonably priced at TJMaxx) and was sad and missed them, so I was willing to spend more on a nicer replacement pair. Fortunately the nicer pair fits well and I do wear them often in cooler weather, with all kinds of outfits.
Or do you mean, you wonder where they went when I got rid of them? Three were taken by the resale shop, and the fourth, the plainest, was donated to a hospital auxiliary thrift shop.