Huge calorie-count.com fan here too. I was an active member of that forum for over a year, during which I lost 20 lbs and dropped approx 4 dress sizes.
When I started I was just edging into the overweight BMI range... a tight size 6p at 5'0" with three chins.... I felt like crap but I didn't look all THAT bad at that weight. I could've stayed where I was at and settled happily into middle aged spread, but I have been pre-diabetic since my second pregnancy and diabetes runs very strongly in my family.
At my annual check-up, my doctor took one look at my blood sugar and other numbers and said, "You need to lose weight or you are on track to be full-blown diabetic in no time at all." He was more worried about my weight than my smoking, believe it or not... but I decided to also quit smoking while I was at it!
So I joined calorie-count.com because I have always found that tracking what I eat is the best way to keep me eating healthy and moderately. And I laced up my sneakers and started a walking program that led to a running program. I set a realistic goal to shed the 20 lbs very, very slowly, over about 18 months. I think slow weight loss is important - the slower you lose, the more likely you will not regain the weight.
I also used a computer program - wish I recalled the name - that enabled me to enter my weight each morning, and record exercise information and other data like cholesterol and blood sugar numbers. Then I could chart and graph and it would tell me - based on my weight alone - how much I was over or under-eating and whether I was on track to reach my goal weight. Very cool program!
I used this program because I had read online that dieters who weigh themselves every day are more successful than those who don't. I used a Tanita scale which comes highly recommended by the calorie-count community. It also tells you your body fat percentage (Guesstimate) and your "true age."
I'm happy to say it's been over a year and I have maintained my wieght loss. I fluctuate between 107 and 110 lbs. Remember, I'm only 5'0" - when I graduated high school I was 103, so my doctor says that is a reasonable weight for me; however, any lower than 107, I start feeling ill and think I look sickly, plus I find it harder to find clothes unless I'm shopping in the kids section. Plus, I was 107 when I graduated college, so I think that is a more realistic weight for me. I find I can go up as high as about 115 without my blood sugar going too whacky, but I use any weight over 110 as my flag to move more and eat a bit less.
I no longer record my food every day, but I do still weigh myself a few times a week. Mostly I just pay close attention to how my clothes are fitting. If my jeans are starting to feel a bit tight, I skip dessert and pile veggies on my plate and work in as much walking as I can.
Best of all: my blood sugar is down to normal again; my cholesterol is also back to normal; my blood pressure (which was always low) is even lower; my GERD is mostly under control - I don't need daily meds for it; and my doctor is very very pleased!
According to my Tanita, my "true" age is only 23 years old (I'm 43). I also took one of those online true age tests that gave similar results and suggested I would live well past 100 years old (helped that I quit smoking too!)