Oh man what an ordeal.
I decided to go to CM and just get them in person while I was in NY today. I went to the Flatiron store first, where they were completely sold out. I had a salesperson call around and she finally found a 2 in the Soho store, but no 4's. I walked down there and tried them on and they were a perfect fit so I bought them for all of $9.
When I got home, there was a package waiting for me. Yep. But when I opened it, they was the wrong pants! They are black with a sort of windowpane pattern. The fit is okay. I think I could go either way as far as size goes, but since I got a 2 and it was such a pilgrimage to get them, that's what I'm sticking with.
Now what to do with these windowpane pants. I don't really need them. I already have 3 pairs of black pants, but since I probably won't be getting the shipping refunded, maybe I should just keep them. I guess I'll post a picture and see what everyone thinks.
Off topic...
I also bought a FABULOUS white short sleeve one button jacket at H&M. It looks more expensive than it really is. Anyway, I also bought this adorable little cream flower pin to put on the lapel and it looked awesome. But when I came home it wasn't in the bag What a bummer. I think I lost it in the fitting room at CM. It isn't even worth going all the way back to the city to get it, even if they did find it. Would it be crazy of me to have them mail it to me? It was only $6, but it really was the cherry on top of this jacket.
