Thanks everyone, your comments have me thinking that I will need to pass on this type of sleeve in the future. As Shelly, and others mention, the 3/4 length sleeve will likely be better; I just have a hard time finding any type of sweater in fabrics I can wear.
Sterling and Diana: Yes. Now that you mention it, they do feel a bit "off" -- much less comfortable than 3/4 length.
Traci - I know what you mean about short sleeves! I have learned to be more thoughtful about short sleeve length since joining YLF...
Echo - thank you for your input and sharing of the "rules". As far as tops go, I think I am looking for traditionally flattering.
Diana: You have touched on something I hadn't considered--I am short waisted as well. I am going to have to try the top on again just to see if that's contributing to my feeling much-less-than-fab in these tops. That's really helpful.