Eileen Fisher Renew - YouLookFab Forum

Category

Shopping

Welcome! Read about what to wear and how to wear it on the YLF Blog. Join the YLF Forum to ask specific questions or just chat about fashion and personal style. Or check out the curated list of things we love in YLF Finds.

Outfits Ensembles Trends Advice

Eileen Fisher Renew

Lesley

Veteran

I just learned about Eileen Fisher Renew, where you can buy used Eileen Fisher clothing. Owning some EF is a minor #lifegoal, and the prices are SO low. I was wondering if anyone has taken any EFR pieces for a test drive, and how worn they might feel.

Shopping

22 replies

Latest reply was from Barbara Diane

Anonymous

I didn't know about this. DH was wondering if they might be returns. Worth checking out in any case!

Jenn

(website)

Veteran

I’d do it in a heartbeat if anything came though that I needed.

I also return all my worn-out EF to the store to be recycled or rehabbed for Renew. They give you a token $5 credit per item

JAileen

Veteran

I would definitely do it. My introduction to EF was through thrifted pieces. I’ve bought a few EF pieces on Poshmark, too.

Jorja

I’ve posted about EFR. The clothes are not returns. Certain EF stores will buy your “gently used” EF clothes for a $5 EF gift card. The clothes are then laundered/dry cleaned/ mended if necessary. There is usually a description of the condition.

The only issue for me was was the item didn’t fit and there wasn’t another size to choose from. So I just keep watching!

With free shipping and returns, it’s worth a try.

rachylou

Veteran

That’s cool!

Lesley

Veteran

Thanks, all! Next question: sizing. Is it a roomier fit than, say, a J Crew or a LOFT?

cat2

Veteran

I think it’s TTS but a more flowy fit.

Joy

Veteran

I have bought several EF Renew pieces and most have been great. I sent something back last year. It was easy and free. I wish that they gave the EF color and not a general color name like blue for all their navy’s so one could get a better idea of the color. Also I wish that they gave lengths on everything, but everything has arrived clean and without odors in like new condition. I am thinking of getting velvet pull-on pants for winter.

Jorja

The Nordstrom website suggests ordering one size down if it the first time purchasing EF. I find the clothing quite a generous fit and usually size down.

Joy

Veteran

That is good advice about sizing down a bit. Tops are more generous than pants and pants run a bit short, more like ankle pants.
I have pieces that fit from xxs ( tube skirts) to Large ( a chunky wool knit cardigan). Petites are too short on 5’3” me most of the time.

April

Veteran

My experience with EF is that the fits are very roomy and that the pieces do hold up well. Love that they're giving them a second life!

Anonymous

I just saw the EF Renew section too even though I've bought things online over the years.

The styles are roomier but it's part of the design, sizing down is a per item adjustment. I've had button downs that were best in a size small but for the boxy knit tops I actually size up because the length in the back is awkward sized down.

Also I wash everything, the linen/cotton mixes tighten up and some of the looser cotton knits get droopy without a little occasional dryer action.

Janet

(website)

Veteran

I have only had a few EF items over the years, but I found sizing down necessary. They’re such nice quality and the colors are pretty — I’m always a little sad that the cuts and fits are not my best.

Angie

(website)

Fashion Stylist

What April said!

Jaime

(website)

Veteran

EF has always been way ahead with sustainability. Definitely roomy fits and great quality in my experience too.

Echo

Veteran

I've always had to size down in EF, in both tops and pants. I really like that these items are making EF available to more consumers and keeping well made clothing out of landfills. The only disadvantage is that they don't say what the cut on the denim is - ankle length? Straight cut? It would be nice if they gave inseam lengths or stated what the product was originally sold as so one could look up the original description.

Joy

Veteran

I agree, Echo, you said that so well. I wonder if a Renew piece will go with EF pieces I already own. Some things on the site look short, like they have been altered, but it could just be the photo angle.

JAileen

Veteran

Update: I bought a lambswool doubleface wool charcoal hoodie. It was described as “good as new”. It had a lot of pilling. A LOT. I have a rechargeable depiller and so I depilled it. Now it is as good as new. I have already worn it several times and love it. It fits my real life.

I would say, though, buyer beware. I noticed in the descriptions that things that were described as “good as new” were missing buttons or had stains. I would not describe anything with stains as “good as new”.

Stagiaire Fash

Veteran

JAileen, thanks for the report! I wonder who is writing the descriptions. I had thought this was like those “certified” used cars where they do an inspection and make sure it hits all the marks, but this sounds more like a shady secondhand swap meet where people can make whatever claim they want. In any event, I’m glad I didn’t follow through with ordering something from them to be delivered to the sister recovering from surgery.

RobinF

Veteran

That's too bad that they aren't describing the condition accurately. I would think they get a lot of returns that way, as well as frustrated customers.

Joy

Veteran

My EF Renew items have been fine but I wish they would give the EF color name and the length. I have bought mostly pants and dresses similar to what I already own.

Barbara Diane

Veteran

I bought one item at the outlet-before being called RENEW they used to be called Green, I had no problem with the quality but of course I saw it IRL. I’ve gotten lots of use out of it.

I wear a variety of sizes in EF.