I would keep all four! I know you are in a warm weather area, so the three quarter sleeve and linen would have a long shelf life. The colors you picked are very neutral, but I know you have lots of color in your wardrobe so they should be the perfect finishing piece. Plus, the price is right! I would be happy to find something I liked in multiple colors. I bought a blazer from talbots this spring that I love, but of the three available colors, I already had navy and red so the only one I could buy was emerald. But if it had been offered in other colors that I didn't have, I would have bought them.

Coming back to report that the item did indeed go on sale and I got a price adjustment! Makes the decision to keep at least three of them (still on the fence re: the gray one) a lot easier!

I am a serial duplicater! If I like something, I would duplicate it in all colors of the rainbow. And if I didn't, I have always regretted it. So you know my answer

Glad you found your HEWI

Well, you have already established that you will wear duplicates often with your pencil skirt collection. As long as the material won't throw off your use, I vote keep. I don't own the Halogen skirts but, are they seasonless material? If so, that could be why they are such workhorses despite owning duplicates, you can wear them year round. If the blazers will be treated the same way I vote keep.

I like Angie's suggestion. Hang them all up, tags on and see what happens in the next month. Return what ends up just hanging around taking up space.