Rambling Ann, fashiontern and Marilyn, thanks for the great questions! Really helpful!
Do I have something else in the same vibe? No, but I do have lots of black and some burgundy and taupe that would go well with it.
I have a black scarf that I def would wear it with. Or a hot pink scarf (eh... speaking of loud accessories) and leave the rest of the outfit black.
I def see it as a casual MOTG coat, like grocery shopping, stepping it up from my usual parka or athletic coat.
I try to be more conscious about my style evolution so that my wardrobe doesn't spill over.
Is it the leopard print or faux fur? I'm attracted to the fluffy part of the faux fur. I can't stand mohair, but I think faux fur would be fun. I'm very ambivalent about the print. I partly assosiates it with showing off in a Kim K kind of way (not so good, IMO), partly with costume dress-up and partly as a classic updated cool rocker chic vibe.
And well, $45 is not too much for a fun test ride. However, I'm drawn to the idea of a strict and coherent wardrobe (maybe another fantasy that should be left as a fantasy)
The Teddy Bear coat looks super cozy!