No 3 looks great. How fun it’s the cheapest.

I was also going to vote 3!

Number 3 looks best with your dresses. Next one is number 2.

Oh, and re price point......I got mine at Old Navy for about 20 bucks. It beat out much more expensive jackets and I love it.

Thanks ladies!

Marilyn, ON was one of the first places I looked... however their current styles are boxy and longer than what I was looking for. Suz has one from there as well. Too bad, as I know their price would be great!

I see many have voted for 3, which is my favorite too, particularly with dresses. I love my new denim jacket!

Joining the chorus for #3. It seems chic and sleek - and v practical!

Didn't look to the comments, nr 3 is the best from here!

Thanks for the input! Much appreciated. No question #3 is the YLF winner!

The other one is taking its good ole time - scheduled to be delivered next week

I’m replying (late to this) without looking at the whole thread first, so it will be interesting to look back and see what others thought.

3 is my favorite, and I like 4 too — the lighter wash can be really useful in my experience (more summery!). I like the shape of 2 but the sleeves are quite long. That’s not necessarily a deal-breaker for me as I often roll sleeves. 1 is my least favorite — seems a bit bulky.

Decision: I'm keeping #3. I ordered #2 in a smaller size, and in a lighter wash, as I liked this one but felt it was just a bit big. Well, the smaller size fit weirdly in the shoulders. And to be honest, I've looked at so many now, I just don't want to keep looking. I really don't think I'll find a fit better than #3. Plus, this was the cheapest of them! I may keep an eye out for another, darker wash one... because as we all know, it's okay to have several denim jackets

Thank you all for your input and help.