Such great advice from everyone!

Cardiff girl, my suggestions are very similar. I’ll preface by saying that you’ve hit quite a big lifestyle change, so that you can probably pass on more than you think. Also, you sound like you keep items for a long time, anyway - which should ease your conscience

Begin by pulling out what you are wearing frequently. Keep. Easy!

Keep sentimental items.

Pass on annoying and uncomfortable items.

Then pull out items that cover a range of events and settings that are less frequent, but possible. But make sure you LIKE THESE ITEMS! Fit them on again. Assess how you feel in them NOW.

What’s left are the items that are questionable and cluttering. Put items you are VERY unsure about into a temporary holding zone.

Attack one season at a time.

Re-evaluate

Amazing thread full of so much excellent advice that I will be rereading it when fully awake . Anyway, one key takeaway is clearly to start with what you actually love wearing. As for the items you love and don't wear, I tend to hang on to things I love and have worn happily in the past but am just not feeling right now, and am more skeptical about things that I think I love and have never worn. Ideally they should be taken out for a test run/outfit lab.

I have nothing to add that hasn't been said, but I'm favoriting this thread to be able to keep referring back to it. I relate to so much that you say because I feel similarly a bit lost about what my life is now and what "new normal" might be. So many of us can relate to being in flux these days.

Thanks for this post.

I've been pretty good of late and only buy essentials or to replace anything that I've outgrown or has worn out to the point that it has achieved rag bag status !

I’ve been asleep !so lovely to wake up to even more advice and suggestions .

Runcarla,yes l remember you retiring and how you went about sorting your wardrobe out.It’s good to be reminded that it’s a process that takes time and doesn’t happen over night.l think once lve decided to do something l can be quite impatient.
Bijou,thank you for commenting.l think that the pandemic ramifications still rumble on much as we are all so over it by now.
Angie,you are right about a big lifestyle change.My husband said the same thing.Thank you for your advice ,wisdom and permission to let stuff that is no longer serving me go.
Jaime,you are so right!Its the pieces l have never worn that puzzle me the most.You know,you love it ,your buy it,you put it on ,take it off and keep it just in case!
Peri,thank you for understanding what’s at the core of this.l hope we all get to settle somewhere good and peaceful soon.
Cee,well done you!

Barbara Diane,you add wise words to the thread,thank you.

What a wonderful thread. I just wanted to add, I think at the start you said there were things you had worn a lot that you weren’t wearing so much now? Might that not just be getting tired of them? And surely there is no need to feel guilty about that? Those are the ones I feel least guilty about. If I have met the #30 wears-and often many more- then I haven’t wasted my money or the world’s resources as they had excellent use? So if I no longer like them, that feels OK and off they go to the hospice shop?

Jenni, Why toss it if it’s in good shape & you principally like it? My friend hurt my feelings a few weeks ago & im not planning to toss him, am just taking a breather.

Cardiff Girl, I recall reading a book called “SHED your stuff, change your life” or something like that. The main point: Editing leaves space, both literal and in your mind for your next creative venture. There is no need to have plans for anything in advance. Uncertainty in this case is good. Obviously, Covid has left all of us with an extra dose of uncertainty! I remember following the advice, editing my belongings and somehow over the next few months the plans for my unique (at the time) career evolved.


Like you, my youngest, 23, just left home, this time for good (I believe). He has paid off his student loans and saved money while working remotely. He recently found a better position and moved to Denver (three days ago). So empty nest…and I have started to edit, although I started with my makeup drawer.

A good portion of wardrobe editing has to be done alone, however, I find it helpful to involve someone I trust with the more difficult and emotionally fraught decisions. A trusted helper can steer you through the fuzzy logic we all experience around items with emotional ties that blur our vision. They do not have those ties. DD28 has become my trusted helper for editing. Sometimes I use a friend, although I find DD more helpful.

I have used many of the suggestions already made above, especially trying things on! So important!! A helpful question for some items may be: Am I able to create an outfit out of something else I already have for (imagined occasion) without this item? If so, which outfit would I prefer to wear? If it’s not the outfit with the questioned item, it goes into the edit bin.

Another helpful strategy is to look at similar items, if you have them, and eliminate the items you use least often, or not at all.


There is no magical way to recover the lost money from something with tags remaining unused in my closet. I have learned from experience that I rarely if ever decide to wear things with tags after the first season they were purchased (unless they are a suit). Keeping them does not reduce my guilt or somehow make the bad investment better. Sunk cost.

If I am too attached and think I may use something again, I put it in a holding zone and set a time limit. My holding zone has containers with future dates. When that date comes I will sort the bins and if I haven’t already pulled out the items, will make a decision to edit from my life or add back to my closet. I have a keepsake box for certain items however, it’s pared down to only a few of the most sentimental.

Jenni,what you say makes sense but the guilt is real!l definitely think that some of those things l struggle to let go off are the things that l wore a lot but no longer do.l think if l wore them a lot before ,l might again!But sometimes it’s good to say thank you for your service and pass it on as it’s time is over .l think that’s one of the valuable points that l can take from this thread.Incidentally my favourite jeans are on 130 wears and still going strong!
Staysfit,you are so right about having another objective eye.My DD is good at this whereas my DH is hopeless bless him.He just wants me to keep everything.In fact he’s banned from looking in any charity bags now as he just gets it all back out again !

To both you and Stagiare, perhaps we are different emotionally about such items. It is true that for my most sentimental items I would keep them. Those that still fit and that I loved and wore that are not as sentimental, but I have nothing similar, I keep also, as I might well want to wear them again after a break. But other things, I can fall out of love with, as it were, and just feel I have sort of worn them to death, even though they may still be in good nick. Those are the ones that get happily donated. I guess with them I have some instinctive sense that they’ve had their day, with me, and I am moving on. I cannot cope with buying nothing at all for like a whole year- maybe several months I can do, but even low numbers like 12 a year mean some donations or wardrobe numbers will inevitably rise beyond what I can manage.

Jenni, I don’t buy nothing all year. I’ve bought 15 items, including bags, workout gear, 3 pr shoes, a jacket, a swimsuit, and 3-4 underwear items on average each year for the past 3. I received 2 items for Christmas and have recorded 1 pr of corduroy pants this year, am scratching my head to see if that’s accurate, but can’t remember anything else. I removed probably a dozen items when I went to the 2nd hand store & 2 pr of shoes were failures. So I guess there is gradual growth, but it doesn’t feel out of hand, particularly as much of the buying is related to settling into a new social & physical climate. I wasn’t barefoot the first winter, but I’m glad to have a few more pairs of boots, for example. Pulling old clothes out makes me happy, probably because I only keep things I like, even if I don’t wear them much. Shopping is a chore I’d rather not do more often. There are things to buy that have been on my list for several years, but I don’t want to chase them down. Rotating existing stock is easier & gives me plenty of variety.

Do you see yourself engaging in volunteer activities that might suggest a particular style of clothing?

Also, after my mom died and MIL moved away, I have very little need for hot weather clothing unless I take an extended trip to a hot clime.

My biggest wardrobe purge has been getting rid of 1/3 of my wardrobe when moving to a smaller house. I pulled out all my black summer tops, for example. If I had 9, I got rid of at least 3. I should have gotten rid of half as I had to add long sleeved transitional items, my new major season. Summer heat which was my major season is now the shortest. I really need very few hot weather items but I like what I have, and have worked hard to gather items for that season. I had hoped things would just wear out and not be replaced, but that has not happened. I have already purged shorts and sandals and most swimwear but I need to purge more.
Figure out the minimum you need for one week and keep that. It helps to have a color preference for the season or even all year. I include a dark neutral, light neutral , a column of each plus at least 2 accent colors that will go with either neutral, more if you get bored quickly. For spring my colors are navy, white, coral and aqua. These continue in summer with some black and cobalt blue sneaking in. Late season I switch to fall colors in hot weather fabrics and styles… browns, rust and orange, mustard and olive green. These colors run through November so a few cold weather items in these colors. Then everything switches to holiday…red, green and metallics, white returns as the light neutral, black as the dark one.
Good luck and be ruthless.

ChrystelJ: your phrase about “a past version of me” really resonates with me right now. I feel like I’m on a bridge about to cross over to a new and different life and I’m not sure if I want to be bogged down with a past version. Lots of great advice here. Right now I can’t improve on the advice already posted.


I can see why some people say, “oh to heck with it! I finally had it figured out and now everything has changed.”

I am generally Team Keep, but do tackle a category at a time and get rid of anything too worn or that never really fit right or is scratchy. E.g., I just winnowed my sandals down to just those that really fit, and it’s so helpful to know I can confidently reach for what is left. I have found that I can remix existing pieces in unexpected ways; all the Angie posts of outfits have gotten me to rethink what I thought went together, and so I am getting more wear out of my older pieces. Maybe tuck the ones you aren’t currently feeling out of sight until you get a similar spark of inspiration?

I don't have much new to add, but I like to do a 'quick' sort first, before a deeper one. In other words, I'll go through a bunch of items to sort them into piles without faffing too long on any one of them (if I find myself doing that, I put the offending item in an 'extra' pile & just get on with the rest).

Then I go back to each pile to sort deeper - often I find that items will stay in their initial piles (i.e. my initial reaction was the correct one), but sometimes I will need to make some extra 'just in case' piles for situations you mentioned (unpredictable weather etc). If I have space, those sorts of piles become an 'out of sight' holding zone. My fantastic YSL Variations jacket (the one I wore to Sal's virtual YLF party) is one such item - I never wear it for my real life (DH nixed the idea of wearing it for my 30th because it's 'too flashy' lol) but I just can't bear to part with it!

And that's ok! We're all allowed to keep some 'illogical' items like this - so long as we have the 'space budget ' to comfortably accommodate them

Donna F,yes l have done quite abit of volunteering pre pandemic,most of my clothes will still be suitable for anything like this but you make a good point,to consider potential future activities.
Joy,you are right,colour palette is always worth bearing in mind especially if we want things to mix and match.l am also eyeing up my shorts and thinking that one pair for the garden might be sufficient!
Ms Maven,you have articulated a lot iof what l was trying to say very succinctly !
Cat2,yes l am on team keep too.l think that’s the problem!I have been keeping for the past thirty years!But you are right we should all try and wear what we have got as much as possible.
Zaeobi,l hear you!l have a non negotiable jacket too and even though l rarely wear it it will not be going.