Anna, do you like the big rolled cuff (on the skinny) or the big folded one (on the straight)? I kind of like them both, I have to say. The rolled ones with the LV high shaft booties are kind of spectacular.
Early last summer (I think?) I bought white selvedge jeans from JCrew that had a deep cuff, and most people here did not like the look at all. The times they are a changin, I think! (Too bad I got rid of those jeans because they were too big. I think they would fit me today, darn it.)