I would like to see more stylings. It looks like it fits fine but maybe the overall length plus the flounce gives it a sweet look that is at odds to what you normally wear. I so wanted a peplum top, having loved them the last go-round, but I have not been able to make them work this time.

Without reading the other responses I'm going to say that I really love it on you. I also think it could look great with a topper which I know you usually wear. I hope you keep it. Now off to read the other responses.

Hmm I'm not totally sold on it but cannot quite pinpoint why.

I usually look for wildcard items that will: A) move my style further in a direction I wish to go but haven't yet, B) incorporate a trend I wish to explore, C) add an element from a shadow style that I don't always indulge, or D) is something that I inexplicably looooove and can't bear not having in my wardrobe.

I do think that the fit is spot on, and that it will look decidedly better with the GAP Resolution crops or a pair of white jeans; perhaps they just need that added graphic crispness to be more "you".