My Miz Mooz combat boots and I parted ways a couple of years ago. I'm debating on two styles and would like to know your opinions--assuming they are equally comfortable. Thanks!

I can't make a find for the Thursday combat boot but here's the link:

I know several people like the Thursday boot "Captain" but it doesn't come in black and it's a little more "granny" style than I was looking for. It's more along the lines of the Frye Natalie lace up and I'm pretty sure I want a more rugged style--but more refined than my navy Docs.