Very interesting discussion! Especially since I do a unique twist on classic and have way too much historical fashion knowledge in my head.
When I read the blog, similar questions occurred to me:
- What is classic?
- What is modern classic versus true/original classic?
- What is a trend and not classic?
For a
classic, I went back to thinking of the earliest version of each item. For example, the white shirt, originally circa 1900, women's version (the shirtwaist) as well as men's, having the same basic shape it has now with tailored body and long sleeves.
The classic version - white cotton, tailored to be neither tight nor oversized, point or round collar, probably single button cuffs
The modern classic - not necessarily cotton, moderate variations on collar and cuffs, can be fluid and less tailored or boxy, maybe use eyelet or woven patterned but still all-white material.
The trend versions - ruffled fronts, oversized or body con fits, bishop sleeves, dropped shoulders, puffed shoulders, unusual seaming, etc.
--> I think the trend version is one that could be easily dated to a decade or more than one decade. Like body con button shirts are early 2000s or puffed sleeves are 80s/90s. They are things that can look dated in not a great way. Carla's example of Converse variations is a great example.
--> So the modern classic is not easily put into a time period box. It's not a boring copy of a men's oxford shirting buttondown, but the essentials are there and not strayed super far from the original.
Ironically, another thought that occurred to me is that many are most of these classic items were menswear in the not-so-distant past. Trench coats and t-shirts were even military items.
To throw a question out there: Crops! Historically, there really isn't a true classic version. There were crops in the 50s and 60s (fairly fitted, the pedal pushers and capris), then wide gauchos in the 70s/early 80s, and I remember knit gauchos in the early 2000s (shudder). But then the last 10 years or more have seen crops in many lengths and - more importantly - styles. Skinny crops, wide crops, flare crops, etc. The original trends were a starting point but the proliferation of styles seems to mean that the idea of the cropped jean or trouser is now a classic one. It's adapted to new silhouettes but crops themselves seem to have become the classic. Or maybe too soon to tell?