#1, #3 and #4 all get my vote of approval. I don't know if you really would want 3 pairs of shoes in the same colour, but it really is lovely. For summer, #1 is my top pick - I can see these being fantastic in hot weather.

Rachy, thanks!

Ledonna, hmm, love for 3 over 6. This surprises me. Thanks!

Style Fan, thanks for your thoughts. I'm rethinking 4, mainly because I'm not sure they add any wearability options that 1 doesn't already. And those are colors I like to wear, definitely!

Ruby Tuesday, thank you for explaining 1. I like them but I didn't understand them, hence my 'are they weird?' question.

Bijou, thank you! I'm trying to de-orphan a light blue bag I have (because I love matchy matchiness), and I thought these shoes in various levels of dressiness would do the trick. I'm having second thoughts about 4, trying to envision how outfits with them would differ from outfits with 1. Maybe there's no difference.

You DO have pretty feet!

I also like 1 a lot! As a bonus, it should be pretty versatile. I like both sneakers.

I will add I have learned from personal experience that it's important to wear sandals that fit like that for a long stretch at home to be sure they don't rub against the ankle - and maybe carry a bandaid or two when you are out and about for your first wears in case a problem develops. But if the fit works out, that style is SO comfortable!

4 are very pretty, but I don't think I've ever noticed you wearing "dainty" shoes, so that makes me feel they don't look like "you". Is that is a style you are wanting to add - if so, they would be a nice choice.

Ryce, thanks! I never in the world thought I had pretty feet. Just pretty big. So all this discussion seems preposterous to me. Thank you, though!

I think you make a good point about 4. I will definitely keep 1, and then either 3 or 6. The thing about 4 is that their uses overlap with 1. 1 has a rubber sole and cushioning, whereas 4 is flat flat flat. I'll have to mull this over some more.

I love #1 and how it looks on you. All the other options are nice too, out of 3 and 6, I like 6 better.

I also love #1, very stylish to me. I would say the sneakers come down to which feels best to you.

Dianna, Robin, thank you! I'm glad you both like 1. They feel pretty good, as I have walked around in them as Ryce suggested.