Fascinating thread. The two Anthropology stores in my area aren't in a convenient location and parking is somewhat of a problem, so unless I am in the area for another reason--usually a restaurant--I don't go there. I do look online and have seen some interesting dresses, but haven't gone so far as to order one.
I am one who is also appalled by the drop in quality and the oversized, boring styles in old reliable BR or JCrew. There are fewer places where I want to shop. I spend as much money as I ever did (and I am a pre-boomer) but in fewer places. I used to like to shop in person, but lately I've done just as well shopping online, where I can quickly eliminate stuff by searching by size, skirt length, price, and so forth.
It's been years since I bought anything at Anthro. One item was a cardigan in a beautiful rose color with a crocheted edge. I had a hard time wearing it until I realized it reminded me of something my Mom would wear in her 80s. My Mom always tried to be well dressed, but I don't aspire to her style at all. Neither does any other woman I know of in my age group.
I hope retailers and designers pay attention to fashion forums and blogs.
Thanks for starting this thread, Lisa.