I have been wanting a black dress purse and missed this out on this when it was in stock a few months ago. I just found it again and I need to BBQ before it sells out.

1) Kate Spade "black" quilted purse. (11x8x2)

I currently own:

2) Black white crossbody/shoulder bag (11x8x2)
3) Red patent clutch (8.5x5.2x2)

Is #1 too close in function to #2? I figured if I was wearing Indian clothes (say blue/purple/gold) then #1 would work better.

The clutch is the minimum size I would ever want to wear for a formal occasion.

Is #1 too big for dressing up? #1 is about the same size as #2 but the strap drop is smaller so it would sit much higher on my body than what you see here

If #1 is too big, then I had also considered #4 (9x6x2) as a potential candidate for a black evening bag but then it bother me that it is so close to #2 in style (same designer)

Thanks in advance!

This post has 4 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.