Bag faceoff: keep one, the other or both?

When I was updating my accessories earlier this spring, I was hell bent on finding a silver bag to carry me through the season. I'm not keen on changing my bags multiple times a week, though some variety is good, so this hypothetical silver piece would see regular service.
I checked out Banana Republic, saw a style I loved in blush, then was told they had the same version in silver available online (see below). Obviously I zipped right home and ordered it. :p
But then, not 24 hours later, I saw the Coach Prince Street Satchell in rose gold and fell hopelessly in love (it's below too). It obviously picked up on my amorous vibes and followed me home.
Now the BR envelope clutch has arrived...and I think I love it too. I can see it being a great alternative, and I suspect it has a bit of a dressier vibe than the satchell? Or not?
What would you do if you were me? Keep Coach, embrace Banana Republic, or make room in your heart/closet/wallet for both?
Your post

Nordstrom

COACH 'Mini Prince Street' Crossgrain Leather Dome Satchel

View Info

Top Pick

Banana Republic

Silver Foldover Clutch

View Info

Top Pick

8 years ago

Joy

Veteran

That's a tough one. The silver looks big enough and simply styed enough to serve as a dressy or day clutch. Will it hold everything you need to carry so that you can get to it easily? Will a clutch be difficult to manage with Reva? If the silver works for you, you should consider keeping both.

Michelle

(website)

Joy, I found myself as an unexpected convert to day clutches this winter when I carried one from Club Monaco. The silver one is even more spacious than the one I used last season and has a little more functionality in the form of an inside pocket. So yes, I know for certain this would be a practical and viable option for me.
For reference, here's the one I carried in the winter.
Your reply

Shopbop

Club Monaco Jane Mayle Coco Bag

A silvery day clutch has been eluding me for some time. Most are too small and formal. If the budget allows, I may have to get your BR find too.
You already know that you love the Coach bag, so that's a definite keeper. The clutch may depend on your budget and what else you need for the season. At least that's the way I'm looking at it when thinking of ordering one.

Joy, the BR clutch is really lovely. The leather is very soft, even with the shinier finish,, and it's extremely roomy.
I bought it on sale, thank goodness, so that helps. Am I right that this could be a multiseason bag depending on when and how it's worn??
Your reply

rachylou

I didn't realise the satchel was Coach. It inclines me more toward it, if you can't keep both. I've loved it in all your outfits I've seen it in. I find the silver clutch a little primitive - it doesn't seem to have the refinements of the satchel.

Firecracker (Sharan)

I'm going to be no help at all. I'd keep both. I like the little nude leather strap on the clutch--you can slip your hand through there as you carry it, right?

Sal

Ooh that are both very nice...if picking just one I would go with the Coach rose gold....if I then had room in the budget I would get the silver too...they are quite different and I think could be worn all year.

Style Fan

Both are lovely but my first choice would be the Coach bag. I see the BR clutch as a second bag in a handbag capsule.

I could see using the BR clutch year round. We could use some shine with our winters.

Ledonna N.

I'm an enabler I say keep both.

Anonymous

Oh no. I love them both. I could see me keeping both of them. I am especially enamored with the shape and color of the Coach bag.

Would it be hard to carry the Banana Republic bag? It seems to me that it might be awkward.

Summer

You seem to love both of them, Michelle, so, if they fit your budget, and they will be functional for you, I would keep both. Sorry to spend your money for you!

My silvery bags are year round workhorses. I have a satchel that is my go-to bag and a larger tote for serious shopping, trips and to events that mean taking a book or notebook.

Sterling, I don't think it will be impractical to carry. I enjoy day clutches in general, and this one does have a handle I can grab if the need arises.

Angie

Fashion Stylist

Make sure you can hold the BR clutch when it's full of your stuff. I couldn't manage which is why the blush version isn't mine. If not - you are good to go.

Interesting! Angie, what happened when you put your things into the blush version? The bag strikes me as structured enough to hold my belongings very well. Curious to hear what happened to you.
Your reply

I found the clutch too big and unstructured to hold in the way it is intended - which is slipping your had through the front handle. Once my stuff went in it, the bag was heavy and slouchy, and I could not clasp its shape with my hand. I have another clutch in a similar design but it's smaller and very structured. It's very easy to clutch with the same style handle.

Hmm. Thanks for that description. I always envisioned just carrying it tucked under my arm like I always do with my day clutches + using the handle only when necessary. I'll try it out when I get home tonight. Appreciate the tip!
Your reply

Staysfit

You absolutely gushed about the satchel in two posts already. I think you must love it. I say keep that one and pass on the silver clutch for now. IMO, I don't think there is enough difference to make it worth two metallic bags. If you want a clutch I think you can do better.

UmmLila (Lisa)

I love the satchel. It makes me sorry I threw away the 25 percent off Mother's Day coupon they sent me a couple days ago.

The satchel is so pretty I think it's really a must keep. The clutch is nice enough but the satchel is thrilling.

Kari

Oh man, I'm a sucker for rose gold. That one gets my vote. It's luscious!

Category