I prefer the black & white, due the colour combo and the quilted sleeves.
Maybe I'm barking at the wrong tree here, but I do believe these bombers (both) look a bit...hm... teeny. I get this feeling from how short they are (hitting at the waist on the pics) and because they have this cuffs both on the waist and on the wrists. I know cuffs are marvellous when it's windy and chilly, but I can't help feeling them as being... less grown-up than plain sleeves.
My reserves, of course, are not to be taken into consideration if you plan to use the bombers only in casual settings.