Ask Angie: should I keep these pumps?

I am going through my fall footwear wardrobe trying to identify the holes (both wants and needs). I am not sure about these red patent Me Too pumps I got 3 years ago. They are not the most comfortable for me because I sized up a whole size because they were a bit tight in the front. Well, even with am insole it is not always easy to keep them on my feet - but they are not causing me pain or anything.
I will be looking for a better replacement for sure but the question is: do they still look OK with this type of toes and gold hardware> My problem is that I only have one other pair of pumps (silver) so my business casual shoe wardrobe is pretty limited on the whole.
Angie, would you say these can be kept until I find a replacement or not? I like the color (it is more true in pic #2) but not sure if toe shape and heel are dated.
Thanks!

This post has 2 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

10 years ago

columbine(erin)

Veteran

Not Angie but I like 'em hehe. But since they aren't comfy you need an update!

UmmLila (Lisa)

The color is nice, but they don't say "this year" to me because of the toe shape. Have you considered a low heeled snake print pump? I know it's a different color entirely but a softer color might be nice.

Sveta

(website)

I would love to find almond or pointy toe pumps to replace those (and snakeskin print sounds lovely) but with my hard to find size and wider forefoot it make take months (if not years) The sad story of my life!

Gigi

Sveta, have you ever tried Shoes of Prey? I have no idea how the quality or pricing are, but they make custom shoes in your size.
https://www.shoesofprey.com/content/sizing.html

Angie

Fashion Stylist

I vote pass on. Seattle shoe shopping - here we come. xo

Suz

I can't wait to see your new fab shoes!!! I know you'll find some, and if not, you'll come back with the resources to do so.

Columbine and Ummlilla - thnak you.
Gigi, thanks for the link, looks interesting.
Suz, I wish you were right but when shoes are concerned I cannot leave it to chance (aka what they have in the store).
Angie, do these Earth wedges have potential you think (option of blue, black or burgundy)?
Also these boots - are they dressy enough? Black or brown for me?
I like these d'Orsay flats but not sure if pointy toe would work for me - they usually don't...but there is no harm in ordering, right?

<sigh> I HATE shopping for shoes!!!

Nordstrom

Earth 'Spiceberry' Pump (Women)

$99.95 $71.41

Sale

View Info

Top Pick

Earth 'Rider' Stretch Tall Boot (Women)

$189.95 $129.90

Trotters 'Signature Posh' Boot (Women)

$274.95 $164.96

Vince Camuto 'Halia' d'Orsay Pointy Toe Flat (Women)

$97.95

marianna

Sveta, Earth shoes have serious arch support in them. Not sure if that works for your feet? They never work for me… it's too much. Those wedges are really nice looking, though.

annagybe

You'd have to order, they're not in stock in Seattle in the snake
http://shop.nordstrom.com/s/ha.....alizedsort

Thanks Anna - do you know if they work for wider toe box? This is my usual problem with pointy toes: they pinch my toes
Thanks Marianna. Do you have high arches? I do...so I am not sure if this is good or bad.

Sveta, I don't have high arches, so maybe the Earth shoes will work well for you!

Thanks Marianna, I think I order them - in all 3 colors

Deborah

Gigi Shoes of Prey provide exceptional quality and they are not cheap, but very fab. I have a pair of their shoes:).

Sveta, I love the colour and the shoe style is a bit of a staple. I find that look is generally always available...classic. But if they are not comfortable let them go:).

Laura (rhubarbgirl)

Wow, that Shoes of Prey link is intriguing - a little pricey, but not exorbitant given they're custom made.

Sveta, I don't hate the shoes, but the combo of the toe shape, the gold links and the patent is giving me a less than current feel, I will admit.

The Earth Wedges are a lot more on trend. My thumbs are up.

Deb, your experience is encouraging. Maybe this is my only chance to get pointy toe kitten heels which are comfortable for my feet? Need to ponder!
Thanks Laura.
Angie, it is a relief to hear I think I will order them to Seattle Nordstrom. What do you think about these dressy boots - worth a try?

L'Abeille

Sveta your original pumps do look really good, just not super current. I hear you though on the pain of letting them go when they do work still, and their replacement may not be easy to find. Could you do something to change them up a bit? Remove the hardware, darken it to change the colour and shine, or cover it up with a kiltie fringe? At least that way you can wear them and feel a little newer (and after all they are this season's dark red...) while waiting on the perfect pair.

Category