I definitely bought it thinking it would be perfect for winters around here, but anyone who had "real winters" would probably veto this as a 'spring skirt'. Around here, it's still too hot for that skirt right now because our summers are sticky and humid, and you won't catch me in dress or skirt in the summer!
I definitely think on my shape, the difference between this and the usual Halogen skirt is the length (this is 27 inches @ size 8) and the regular Halogen comes a few inches shorter. I also can't wear skirts low on the waist, and this is long enough for me to sit it where it needs to be, and also still cover my knees.
Beth Ann, if you're nearby to a Nordstrom, I'd go in and try it - but with such mixed reviews, I too would be hesitant to purchase it online. I hate online letdowns!