Angie, I checked out my nearby AT yesterday but they don't carry the turtlenecks in store. I was going to order online today since there is a promotion going on, but I thought I should ask you what your impression is of the sizing. My experience with AT is that I am usually a size small (or a 6 in numbered sizes), but knits are sometimes more of a question.
Since I'd be wearing these with layers over top, I don't mind them being a bit close fitting, but I don't want them to be too tight. What do you think?