I have a pair of Clarks shooties (quite similar to the models below; mine are few years old so I was not able to find exactly the same) which are sadly on their last leg (pun intended). I'm looking for a replacement with the following criteria:

Closed enough to wear in late fall/early spring.
Dressy enough to wear with trousers.
Heel up to 2.5 inch.
Very comfortable.

I would be happy enough to replace them with another pair of very similar Clarks, but if there are other shoes out there that can be equally comfortable I'm eager to try!
Thank you all!