Darn it, everyone -- you were all supposed to be in agreement and make this decision easy! Now I'm going to have to decide for myself!
I was leaning towards pair 3 (the one in pics 4+5), but now I don't know. Angie, what do you mean by eye droop? I read about that in your blog post, but I wasn't quite sure what it meant, or what I was supposed to look for to combat it. Is it that the corners of the frames are sort of pointing down, rather than up?
And #2 seems to be the crowd favorite! Wow. So confusing. #1 and #2 are about $100 more than #3 and #4 (though I might be mistaken). If it's really the one I want, though, I'm trying not to be too price-sensitive, since it's such an important decision and it will get amortized over so much use.
As for number 4, I do think the shape is pretty cool. It comes in several colors. I have the red on, but it also comes in some VERY brights (purple and turquoise I think!), and some neutrals. Is the red good for me? It's kind of a shimmery (almost glittery) up close. Would a neutral be better?
The first store I went to (pairs 1, 2), the guy helping me told me to come back during the week, when their magic glasses specialist with 25 years of experience picking glasses for people will be there. Maybe I'll go back and try them on again.
Thanks so much everyone! You haven't heard the last of this!