I've always had a problem with mascara making my eyes itch and I just found out why. With my colouring I wear a brown mascara and it is quite possibly the red dye in the brown colouring. Same brand I will react to two different tubes differently and that is quite possible as the dye might be a bit more in one than the other.
In comes fake lashes. While I have never ever worn them before I have to say they are a blessing. I am able to wear them all day with no itching at all. We used the lashes that are all on one strip and the style called natural. 3 or so lashes with a space then 3 or so more, etc. A little longer than my regular lashes but not by much.
NO MASCARA at all, just the lashes and oh boy wonderful.
So if you have this problem it might be worth a try.