3 Denim Shirts - Help Me Decide

morethanbeige

Hi all! Please help me decide which denim shirt works best.

1 - 3 I've posted this before from the dressing room. It's Joe's Denim Shirt
4 - 7 Levi's Denim Shirt (thanks to tip from modgrl)
8 - 10 Banana Republic

Thanks! All comments/critiques welcome.

This post has 10 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

14 years ago

Shopping

26 replies

Latest reply was from Amy

Astrid

Veteran

I don't like the light wash of the first one. I definitely prefer the last wash, it's dressier. But I like the fit of the second one best, the third one has too much fabric in the waist. You could take it in, but I don't know if it's worth that effort. Not much help, I know!

ETA: The second one seems to pull across the bust, I just noticed. It looks like there's a bit too much fabric above, do you see the two folds? I'm not sure if this is as noticable IRL.

14 years ago

mamaKate

Veteran

Definitely number 3. The distressed look seems a little, well, faded. the middle one - something is off on the fit and/or the pocket placement. The last one is the most flattering and the best color on you, too. BTW I love how you styled them!

14 years ago

Kirti

(website)

Veteran

I like the levi's one the best

14 years ago

Transcona Shannon

Veteran

I love the classic Levi's shirt - the fit is excellent. I think that the faded wash, although the shirt is lovely, is not as versatile and the 3rd shirt has too much fabric in the back.

14 years ago

missvee

Veteran

I like the mid-blue colour of the second one, but why is it bunching up above the bust? Is it just the way you're standing? #1 fits well and with the faded wash it is very casual. #3 seems to be a bit loose in the back (pic#9) but again that could be the way you're posed. So I guess I'm saying that they all have possibilities! Sorry - no help at all...

14 years ago

Travelgal Nicole

Veteran

I like the Levi one or the BR one. Its the wash on the BR one that I like most.

14 years ago

morethanbeige

Veteran

Thanks for the feedback. The pull on the Levi's shirt above the bust, I think, is because the button is undone and falling a bit. When I button it, it doesn't do that.

14 years ago

kellygirl

Veteran

I love the second one. The first and last seem too light and dark, respectively. The mid blue looks like it would be tres versatile!

14 years ago

Jonesy

Veteran

To my eye, the second one is almost tops, but I think it's pulling a bit at the bust (see those horizontal lines emanating from your armpit in pic #6?) which is making it get hung up and do that V thing on your chest...how does a size up look? Too big? I like the BR one but agree that from the back it's not the best fit. Seems like you need one with a nice, tailored fit through the waist.

14 years ago

Kate

Veteran

Don't love the light wash of #1; both #2 and #3 look good. I have a slight preference for the BR shirt, which is more formal than the Levi's one.

14 years ago

Jjsloane

Veteran

I like the Levi's and the BR. Whichever you feel best in is a winner!

14 years ago

morethanbeige

Veteran

Thanks for your comments. I am liking both the Levi's and the BR for different reasons.

14 years ago

Angie

(website)

Fashion Stylist

I like the BR one best. The Levis fit is too small. But it might be worth sizing up and comparing the two.

I also really like the Joes. Different wash and just as fab.

14 years ago

D'Ellen

Veteran

I like the Joe's and the BR. I think the light wash could be fun for summer.

14 years ago

chewyspaghetti

Veteran

I like the BR one best.

14 years ago

modgrl

(website)

Veteran

Oh no, I can't decide! I like the br best because it fits you best, I like the Joe's one too and I think the Levi's one has potential if it was a touch bigger....

14 years ago

Suz

(website)

Veteran

BR fits best by far and I like the dark wash; I also like the wash of the Levi's but not the fit. The light one is good too, for a completely different look.

And I am very grateful to you for this photo montage because I am also in the market for a denim shirt and this shows me what a few of them are like!

14 years ago

Mellllls

Veteran

i like the levis one.

14 years ago

taylor

Veteran

I actually like #1:)

14 years ago

Carole

Veteran

I like the second and the third. I love the darker wash of the last, but the second might be more versatile. I'm just wondering if you would wear a darker wash as much in the spring/ summer. If thats not an issue, that would be my choice.

14 years ago

Anonymous

I vote for the BR one.

14 years ago

nancylee

Veteran

This is tough. But I'm going to vote for #2. I like the shape and color best. I"m thinking the dark wash on the BR shirt might be less versatile.

14 years ago

Queen Mum

Veteran

Haven't read the other responses but the BR looks best to me.

14 years ago

Kappy

Veteran

I like the Joe's and the BR ones. They are so different you should get them both!

14 years ago

modgrl

(website)

Veteran

How would you wear it? I find myself reaching for my denim shirt that is closest to the Levi's the most. I hardly ever wear my light wash denim shirt, though it may work better for you because of your blond hair.

14 years ago

Amy

(website)

Veteran

I don't like how the Levi's shirt fits you. There are some strange pulling lines on it. The BR one gets my vote.

14 years ago

Category