All of your comments are very appreciated and helpful!
I see most of you don't seem to have such a poison eye for this look.
Approprio, you pinpointed it I think: it's the booties. Alone, they're fine, even cool I find. With this suddenly they become 1980.
It's so funny you mention they would go in Amsterdam. I bought them last year as I was smitten by the show "Dicte" from Denmark, in which women are all sporting this kind of cool, cool booties and also cool jewelry. Ok Denmark is not the Netherlands, but it's not too far! (compared to North America). I wonder if fashion there is similar.
The Cat, I find it interesting you want to pair the striped top with black, it didn't occur to me to do this, now I will try! It sounds like a great idea and I'm very excited to do this, it will be like having a new top
Some of you suggest, like Delurke,that they would wear it minus the cardi. I will also try this myself. Maybe a different jacket would change everything.
Some of you, like Liz, would swap the booties for trainers and I will also certainly give this a try too. I have both white and silver.
Jenni, when you wear that jumper, make sur eto take a pic and post it here! I'd love to see it.