Thanks everybody, for the replies!
Staysfit, I appreciate you starting things off in the respectful tone I intended. “Atleisure” is a very useful concept to insert into this conversation.
La Ped, the blurred lines you describe totally make sense to me. I agree with you on which side of the line merino and the other things you mention belong on, but that’s the point, isn’t it? The examples you gave are really useful, because they are very different than the activities I generally think of. When I think of “work out gear”, I’m primarily thinking of what you’d wear for basketball, weight lifting, yoga or maybe casual football—much more urban activities than hiking & other things you suggest. That clarifies why I think of “gear” as adjacent to “urban” while others do not.
Toronto, when we moved to Tampa, I hit that pack of suburban moms in spandex head on. I felt so underdressed and sloppy next to their gear! But I can see what you mean about not wanting to wear it 24/7.
Kkards, great examples. The distinctions between types of leggings are generally pretty clear to me irl. Basically, gear is made to breath while other leggings are made to stay warm, or just mimic pantyhose/tights. But those shirt examples I’m going to have to dig into. To me, they both look like tops I’d wear under a sweater. I’m also reminded of one of Ms Mary’s outfits which incorporated a swimming rash guard, and still looked splendid for her day as a lawyer.
Susie, interesting about gear & a sporty style. I would not define my style as sporty—I don’t like fashion sneakers or jeans, for example. But I do like the freedom of movement and comfort that true sports shoes give me. Some athleisure items offer that as well, whereas others, despite being made by gear companies, wind up being difficult to wear while doing even the mildest movement in everyday life—not turning on sports mode, but just chucking something back and forth with my son, running for the train, taking a long walk. I guess I need two definitions of athleisure: A is what has been defined above—stuff that has the lines and looks of sports, but isn’t made for it and B things that are not made for sports but use patterns and fabrics that are easy to move in. For me, some sundresses and skater dresses are in the latter category. They aren’t sportswear, but if they are the right fabric, they let me do my thing without getting in the way.
Interesting comments about how many clothing items began as gear and moved into daily life. Someone posted an article to Inge’s links live a while back that talked about this, including early tennis clothes.