My kids are keeping me hopping today, so apologies if this is disjointed, but thanks for the input so far! If there was a reliable colour person here in Vancouver I'd definitely go that route, but I just can't. Frustrating!
A couple of things:
Warm-toned makeup and nail polish always looks the most natural on me. Warm brown eyeliner, coral lips, gold/warm brown/peach-based eye shadow, peach blush (a la Nars Orgasm), coral or warm pink nails.
My eyes are definitely a soft, muted green. They are not bright.
I used to highlight my hair light blonde, but when I look back at photos I think it made my skin look red.
I'm usually drawn to navy, ink, black, olive, cream/ivory, blush, and gray, and non-primary, slightly muted colours in general. The brighter colours I like are a coral-ish bright red-orange, cobalt, berry colours, and teal/turquoise (medium to deep, not light). I'm not sure those are necessarily the colours that suit me most, though! I truly can't tell.
deb, I think I wear silver and gold equally well? I'm not sure. I usually wear yellow gold.
torontogirl, the shirt in #15 in black and the striped one in the pics with makeup is navy and cream. Hmm. I'd discounted summer because I thought I was probably on the warm side, but these colours here seem like all my favourites:
http://www.pinterest.com/pin/160792649168753812/