I like both! I don't see a sheerness issue in the photos. Those lightweight tops can be a life-saver when it gets hot!

Please keep the second top. 7 is SO pretty. I like the kimono top tucked in. Cute print.

First, your pink pants suit is totally a killer. I haven't yet had the opportunity to say it... so here it goes: it is a killer, you look terrific on it!

I love the print top and strongly recommend you keeping it. (I wouldn't mind getting one for myself, but we've figured Zara and me aren't best sizing buddies).

Regarding the cream one... well, I find it to be a bit sheer. Surely not in a bad way, and since the lace is so feminine and cute, I would also say go and keep it! Great picks.

Way late to join the thread, but I love the shape and print of #1. The sleeve and neckline would be a dealbreaker for me, but they're beautiful on you. Yes, it's bolder than your signature look, but maybe you're drawn to these items because you want a little more punch in some of your tops. These are both easy to dress up and down, which I do think it essential if they are going to "earn their keep" in the closet.

Both are gorgeous additions to your wardrobe! Did you keep both?