What to return? Gap/Piperlime order with YLF suggestions

Leave it to the forum! I've had this gift card for so long and returned everything... now I've ordered based on your suggestions and I don't know what to send back!

1-3 - Rich & Skinny rust jeggings. I would probably not wear these with a tucked top, but I showed the hip area in pic 3 anyway. Really dig the color, and it is one of my go-to neutrals in my wardrobe.

1 - Una's cashmere sweater, as suggested by MNsara. A totally different shade from my bright lemon F21 sweater, plus it's obviously warmer and softer and better in every way. I think the color is great, too.

2 - Gap Pure tee as suggested by Denise. I do not currently have a basic white tee. This one fits nicely - not clingy, and not too deep a V-neck.

So... what would you vote off the island??

This post has 3 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

13 years ago

Mellllls

Veteran

Please don't return the jeggings. Love them on you.

Elly

very hard because i love the sweater and jeggings i'd be tempted to keep both

Do you have to return something?

Atlantia

Love those jeggings, they MUST stay.

Mochi

I'd vote off the t-shirt; it's a little sheer. Unless you're okay with that. But anyway the leggings are awesome and you must keep. You could probably luck out and find a decent white tee at a goodwill or somewhere.

Angie

(website)

Fashion Stylist

Leggings and the citron top are KILLER!

And now I'm REALLY late

Anonymous

Dang it, if you must return go with the tee and the sweater. those pants are awesome.

deb

#1 - pants, #2 - sweater, #3 - tee, My order of keep items.

Agreeing with the others and Deb's ordering if you must send anything back.

I vote send the t-shirt back. I have several Gap Pure shirts and hate how they launder up. Not worth your gift card dollars! Love the pants and sweater on you. The hair is awesome, too, btw!!

rae

Hm, I suppose I *could* keep more than one. I could look at it like buying a pair of jeans and getting a free cashmere sweater...

Anne, thanks for the heads up on the Pure tees!

Suz

Keep the jeans and the sweater! Gorgeous!

And oh, Rae - i need to tell you - with your shorter hair you may find styling some necklines challenging or at least different for a while. It sort of shocked me (even though I'd been mostly short-haired all my life) -- all of a sudden the proportions seemed to change and the necklines that were tough with longer hair worked great while others didn't seem quite as good. Not saying that's an issue here, but seeing your haircut again reminded me.

Shelley

Active Member

Agree with everybody else that everything looks great, but if something has to go back it's the t. I don't agree with you that you can't tuck with the jeggings. They look great.

ManidipaM

Agree with others: hang on to the pants! The tee does look most dispensable, but if you need one and have been missing a good white T-shirt for a while, the sweater's the one that should go --- though it IS hard to advise this, because it sounds as lovely as can be (I go more by feel than appearance with sweaters generally; you know it looks great).

Amy

The jeggings are fab!

catgirl

Oh, the sweater - looks fantastic of course, and it is a different color from your F21 version. Also love the jeggings. A good white tee is hard to find (though Flannery O'Connor did not say exactly that) but I am in agreement that of the three, it's the least profound.

MNsara

I'm loving that sweater on you - and I don't think it's just because I'll be your triplet Una copycat that I am!

The jeans look fab too, and that's definitely one of your colors. Should go nicely with lots of tops and jackets you already own, right?

Tee is fine, but it's a tee, and what anne said would worry me. Unless cocolioin pointed you at the specific one(s) she's successful with, or if her laundering is different. . .

What size did you get in the sweater? I am dithering between M(good in the bust) and L (hangs better over my hips). I want some slouch, but can't tell if it will stretch/shrink.

JulieJohn

Ok, now you've got me salivating - I really want to see those jeggings with the new lighter Demeulemeester boots!

Category