The forum has spoken - SERIOUSLY you need to keep these items they are all just that good and the coats are absolutely different. The Smyth is just amazing, but its not an everyday coat.

Well I think they are so different and so FAB that you should keep both as long as it fits your budget. In my limited experience great coats do not come often and when they do depending on your climate are workhorses.
One has to have outerwear everyday in the cold season so it is nice to have a variety. Keepers!

I give two thumbs up AND a big toe to those pants! You look faaaaabulous! They work beautifully with your sneakers and sandals!

Okay. The coats... phew... this is a tough one! I want to enable you for both, because they both look gorgeous. But I don't know what you already have, or how much of the year you need outerwear.

You look FANTASTIC in everything!

Oh man those pants look great on you ! Well , everything looks great on you but …
I had my eye on these too but they sold out right away . If budget allows , I say keep it all . These are wonderful , classic-with- a -twist pieces .

I want to answer your question about the coats but can’t get past how fab you look in the black pants/white blouse outfit!

Ah ladies you are all so beautifully supportive! Thank you all for your thoughts and suggestions and bossiness! IM KEEPING IT ALL!
just some quick responses to specific questions:
Janet , pants are a poly/spandex blend, 88/12 if I’m not mistaken
Adding a photo of the product code if that is helpful to search for the item.
Staysfit, stalk the Smythe coat. With your height and colouring it would be gorgeous on you.
Windchime, appreciate your warning about the slits. It sounds like you you took a serious tumble!! I have klutz tendencies myself so will definitely be cautious!

Yay!!! So glad to hear! I don’t think you’ll ever regret your decision. You can hang out in no buy land until the overload passes. Should not be hard with so many beautiful pieces to play with!!! Congrats!!