To the extent that "no-brainers" exist in my fashion world, it applies to clothing items once I have them in my closet. I am trying to do my heavy lifting more in terms of the acquisition process and less in terms of my daily dressing routine. This is a work in progress. I am on team trousers and I find that I can style them once I decide they are for me and play with other items. If I have the right pair of jeans (straight legs at the moment), the right pair of killer black cigarette pants, the right silk track pants, the right casual linen pants, etc., I am good to go with some deliberation and playing around at home time. It takes effort, but feels manageable once I decide to try them on with tops and toppers.
That said, I have brought home skirts that haven't been worn in almost 2 years. I have not invested any time into figuring them out. They probably are not and never were the right skirts for my style, but I never gave them a chance either. At this point, if 2 perfect for me skirts were delivered by a fashion fairy godmother, I would love to wear them. Oh well, I am realizing I have made great progress with pants.
Handbags are the true no brainers for me. I love them, practice PPP religiously and don't find it stressful to decide who gets to come out and play. Ironically, what makes them no-brainers is that I already know exactly what I want from them function and appearance-wise, quickly can ruling them in or out when shopping. I have the same sensibility about footwear, but find the fussy foot factor obliterates my style clarity way too often.
Una- thanks for starting such an interesting thread. As always, I am learning a lot from everyone here.