They are all flattering. Yay for #1!

I think they all look great, but I think that #1 is the best for graduation. I think that you especially look great in the black one.

I think the shoes work. I also like it with the sandals you were wearing when you tried it on! It's such a fab dress on you that people aren't going toot ice your shoes. You truly shine when you wear it. I think you made the right choice. Enjoy!

@Staysfit: Really? I guess I have more footwear options than I thought. I would never have thought the flat black ones would work. After seeing Aquamarine's Graduation WIW, I'm thinking metallic might work too. Thanks so much for chiming in. I know you are an expert when it comes to dresses!

late to the party but #1 hits it out of the park. so gorgeous and not a style everyone can wear. but you look terrific...also looking closely at your shoe choices for inspiration....thanks for posting

Glad you got #1 - it looks GREAT!

The shoes look good!

Perfect...and versatile! You can wear this again and again.

Even better with the footwear Kelly - all sorted. You look stunning in this dress...seriously

You look stunning, Kelly. I especially love the dress with the footwear and clutch you selected. Great picks. And I think your kitty approves.

#1 is perfect for graduation!

Well I'm real late to the game glad 1 came home with you. You look hot like fire in that one. Did you bring any of the others home with you?

Just had to add my compliments. You look fantastic in that dress! I like it with the heeled sandals but also with the flat black ones, for a more casual look. And like Janet, I'm impressed and a little envious how great you look in all of the dresses.

I love them all! #1 is perfect for the graduation, and #2 really suits your figure. Amazing job!

I haven't read all the other replies since you bought the dress - and YAY - that is so nice on you! But I will admit I'd like to see a shoe with more contrast going on - or in a stronger colour . I think the dress needs a strong shoe to balance the graphics. I'd go with a colour, or black or white.