Wow, this was one tough voting! I have practically a tie for all three jackets (11:11:10) - no wonder I could not make my mind in the store!
After considering all these opinions and playing around in my closet I am leaning towards keeping a red one and a brown one. I really need an outerwear jacket and the red one fits this need the best. It is also cropped so I can wear it with dresses and pants. On the other note this one is the most expensive of the bunch - oh, well! This will be my birthday splurge!
The brown jacket is more of an indoor jacket. I have wanted to have an indoor leather jacket for quite a time! I will play a bit more with it to see how this fabric trim fits. The price is so good on it and this is a factor as well. At first I bypassed in on the hanger but then I saw it on the SA with a turtleneck and jeans and really liked the effect!
Lisa, my trench is purple-red and pretty different from this red in color. I don`t really know if I suit cool or warm red better...
Both brown and red go better with my color palette than the black one so this is another consideration. And of course this was what Angie voted

Thanks for all your help, ladies. I cannot express enough how valuable it is - yay for YLF!