April, The length was good (I think?) but there was too much fabric at the torso. The chest was in the wrong place. If my boobs were about 3" lower or double DD's, it would have been perfect. This is really my biggest fit problem with all clothes, and why I have to shop in petites. I remember you saying that you normally shop in regular sizes so it may work for you. Sarah had the small on recently and she is only 5'2". It looked wonderful in her pictures although she said it was too tight across the shoulders.
The only thing I'll say about this coat that I really didn't like is that it's heavy. It is not really a blazer, it's super warm. I don't think I could wear it all day as part of an outfit... maybe for kicking around errands on the weekend but not to work. It's more like a short winter wool coat.