I like 'em all, but I have a particular fondness of 1&2. I think Targets are increasingly like Macy's: good ones and "meh" ones. Oddly enough, my "good target" is actually over the border in Wisconsin -- and Kenosha is not, um, "urban."

Wow! Thanks. Opinions are across the board. I was going to return this weekend but I think I'll wait a bit and see which ones work best in my closet--I will have to try some layering and mixing and matching.

@CC: I am sorry to have sent you on a wild goose chase. Honestly, I don't get Target at all either. Their website, even after their "upgrade," still sucks. For the life of me, I can't figure out why they can't get their act together in that department. I haven't seen any nice sweaters in my local Target either and I couldn't find the ones I bought on the website. It's so weird!
@Suz: Sorry that your Target is so terrible. It's so sad to look forward to a store opening only to find out that it is sub, sub, sub par!
@BethAnn: Lol. I think I should have said "suburban." My Target borders on the rural.

My favorite is #1, but they all look great on you!

I should have added that I like the striped best for you and your IT shape, it's the most flattering. It wasn't about which prints I personally like or don't. Funny that #4 was the one you were not going to keep.

Why am I confuzzled by this array? I am not sure - I think I prefer the ones with black and stripes. More vivid. I'm not loving any of the light grey sweaters I've seen around here - I preferred Janet in the dark houndstooth too. Because my sugar eye is for black.