The cases for work-out wear, gear, and jewelry.
I’ve revisited my thinking on what “should” go into a 30 X 30 capsule. In this post, I chose to exclude gear, but included work-out wear and jewelry. I’ve had some second thoughts about this. And, also, I know that this exercise is meant to be tailored to fit and helpful/elucidating for each participant--so there are no "real" rules. I've jotted down these thoughts, mostly, for any help that they might give others who are capsule-crafting.
Re: Gear—I chose to exclude gear because this is a fashion forum and gear is not so fashion-y. (Well, mine isn’t.) But I do wear gear daily. I wear muck boots at the dog park and I choose from among four water-repellant, parka-y coats for my lengthy dog walks and for running errands if the weather is inclement. Thinking more generally, by eating into the 30-item-total, the inclusion of gear would bias the challenge against those who live in extreme climates and require more gear. There is probably happy medium in which a dress coat or trench is counted and parka is not.
Re: Workout Wear—I chose to include work-out wear, but struggled with overall item count and kept too few pieces to form a useful workout capsule. But, more importantly, I reconsidered the basis for including work-out clothing in the item count and decided that work-out clothes should NOT be included. Work-out gear is necessary, special purpose, and doesn’t usually cross-over with one’s daily fashion. We are NOT talking about people who wear yoga pants all day! If you do that, you have to count it! Making exercisers count work-out clothing unfairly limits the number of fashion items they can include in the capsule relative to individuals who do not work out. Since working out (and the clothing required) is additional to the daily fashion requirement, I think it should represent additional items in the count. Again, there is a leveling of the playing field element to this decision.
Re: Jewelry—I chose to include jewelry in the 30-item-count. Upon reflection, I think jewelry should be excluded from the count. One thing we’ve heard/read forever is that we can change-up the look of a small wardrobe through creative accessorizing. Counting jewelry negates this powerful, wardrobe-stretching technique. I vote to exclude jewelry—and maybe accessories, too—from the count.
Again, I know that there are no real rules to this capsule challenge. Just some mental gymnastics as I continue to refine my capsule.