I like them all and think they fit various outfits and silhouettes. We certainly couldn't do without FFB neutrals but my faves for S/S are 2, 9 and 12-these 3 are not only cheery but looking more current and not at all tired- so, dare to be bold more often! Not much help I know!:-(

I didn't notice so much in the original pics, but in the close up ones I'm not sure about the shoulder fits. They seem a little wide-though could be what's under also. I say try them on in context of what you'll be wearing them with.
And-if you decide to get new, buy together with something you'd wear it with. Then you know you'll be happy with proportions and layering.
Colorwise I definitely think you should have a light neutral, blush, yellow and red!

My initial reaction is that #6 and #7 don't fit you as well as they could. I don't think the proportions of them are flattering on you, however maybe they are better with dresses?

My BR denim jacket bleeds colour as well, which is really disappointing. I haven't done anything yet to try to fix this, but I do intend to. Instead I just make sure I'm wearing it with dark clothes underneath.

And I like the blush Zara jacket, a lot.

Hard to tell the wear issues from photos.

I like your plan though... grouping then replacing the "worst" in each group is very smart.