Oh man, I'm allowed to have more than one? Hurrah!!

I think three:

1. Flat patent leather (dressy casual)
2. Kitten heel, fabulous (dressy)
3. (On the hunt for) Flat, matte leather, more casual riding boot

Sometimes my patent leather boots just seem to dressy to wear with tights and a cotton dress. I think matte black boots would be the very thing.